The demand for education is often viewed as a pure human capital good
and hence treated like an investment. Medical education, like other ty
pes of education, should also have some consumption value. However, be
cause of the high pecuniary returns to medical education, this particu
lar type of schooling is often viewed by the public purely as an inves
tment. An alternative (consumption) view focuses on medicine as a voca
tion in which a certain percentage of the population will answer the c
alling to practice medicine, possibly deciding to practice independent
of income considerations. The current paper examines the investment a
nd consumption features of the demand for medical education, using med
ical application data over the 1948 to 1994 time period. A variant of
a pure human capital (investment) model, and a model augmented by cons
umption and demographic variables, are set forth and examined using me
dical education data. We find that, when predicting demand into the 19
90's, a basic, static human capital model best forecasts applicant act
ivity. [JEL I11] (C) 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.