Objective: To study the relationship between the proliferative capacit
y, represented by the immunohistochemical labeling index (LI) of proli
feration marker Ki-67, and the p53 status, as in theory an intact p53
cell cycle checkpoint system should result in a lower proliferative ca
pacity. Study Design: From a group of 128 patients with a T2 laryngeal
carcinoma, presented from 1989 to 1993 at the University Hospital Utr
echt, 20 patients with recurrent disease and 16 patients without recur
rent disease were randomly selected. All patients received primary irr
adiation. Methods: Denaturing gradient gel electrophoresis and immunoh
istochemistry determined the p53 status. MIB-1 staining was used to de
termine the Ki-67 LI. Results: In 36% of specimens we found a p53 muta
tion with overexpression (LI, 31%). In 8% a p53 mutation without p53 o
verexpression was found (LI, 18%). Forty-two percent showed no mutatio
n but, nevertheless, overexpression (LI, 35%). Neither mutation nor ov
erexpression was found in 14% (LI, 38%). No correlation exists between
p53 status and proliferative capacity of tumors (analysis of variance
[ANOVA]; P =.104). The proliferation rate as established with Ki-67 L
I positively correlates with response to radiotherapy (P =.006). Concl
usions: 1. Overexpression of wild-type p53 protein does not result in
cell cycle arrest measurable by a lower Ki-67 LI in comparison with ca
ses overexpressing mutant type p53 protein. 2. A high Ki-67 LI correla
tes with a favorable response to radiotherapy.