Jn. Hutchinson, A SMALL-SCALE FIELD CHECK ON THE FISHER-LEHMANN AND BAKKER-LE-HEUX CLIFF DEGRADATION MODELS, Earth surface processes and landforms, 23(10), 1998, pp. 913-926
The paper considers the development of initially straight, steep rock
cliffs, bounded above and below by horizontal surfaces, in which basal
debris removal is zero and degradation occurs by the weathering away
of fine debris from the cliff face to form a scree at its foot. Of the
slope degradation models available, the two earliest and simplest, na
mely the Fisher-Lehmann and the Bakker-Le Heux models, are regarded as
most relevant and are briefly summarized. The main purpose of the pap
er is to check the predictions of these models, particularly with rega
rd to the shape of the rock surface buried beneath the scree, against
field data, Such data are sparse. It is concluded that the best field
case currently available, despite its small scale, is that provided by
the 1.75 m deep ditch which forms part of the experimental earthwork
in the chalk on Overton Down, Wiltshire, The predictions of the two mo
dels are checked against field measurements made of the stage of degra
dation reached on each face of the ditch by July 1968, eight years aft
er its excavation. These stages were influenced to different degrees b
y the presence of a surface turf layer. For the NE face, where this in
fluence was least, the agreement of the predictions of the Fisher-Lehm
ann model with the actual rock profile is excellent and that of the Ba
kker-Le Heux model only marginally less so. For the SW face, as expect
ed, the agreements are somewhat less close. These results may be to so
me extent fortuitous because of the influence of the turves and becaus
e the scree slopes tend to be concave rather than rectilinear, as assu
med. Also, the free faces decline with time in a manner intermediate b
etween those assumed in the two models. Larger scale field checks are
clearly desirable before firm general conclusions can be drawn. Rates
of crest recession for the Overton Down ditch are logarithmic with tim
e after a very rapid initial phase. Extrapolation from the early phase
of this logarithmic behaviour leads to a close estimate of the time n
eeded for the slope to develop fully. The associated ultimate crest re
cession is also closely predicted by equations derived from both model
s. (C) 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.