50 families with a history of colorectal cancer were divided according
to whether criteria for hereditary non-polyposis colorectal cancer (H
NPCC) were fulfilled totally (A, n=19) or partly (B, n=31) and stratif
ied by the demonstration that at least half the cancers tested per fam
ily were positive for DNA replication errors (RER+). Accepted clinical
and pathological characteristics of HNPCC were found to cluster withi
n 12 A/RER+ families in which the mean number of affected individuals
per family was 10 . 1. Reliance upon clinical data alone may result in
over-diagnosis of HNPCC, in small families who just meet the minimum
criteria, whereas underdiagnosis is rare. The criteria could be refine
d by inclusion of RER status.