Objective: To learn if paratonia predicts frontal cognitive impairment
s. Background: Paratonia, an alteration of tone to passive movement, c
an be divided into oppositional paratonia (''gegenhalten,'' ''paratoni
c rigidity'') and facilitory paratonia. Although paratonia has been th
ought to be induced by frontal lobe dysfunction, previous studies sugg
est that paratonia does not correlate with cognitive impairment. Howev
er, only oppositional paratonia has been studied in this manner, and i
n these studies only the presence or absence of paratonia was assessed
instead of a quantitative scale. Facilitory paratonia has not been st
udied for its relation to cognitive function. Methods: Twenty-five pat
ients evaluated for degenerative dementia were assessed on semiquantit
ative 5-point scales for paratonia by two independent raters. A quanti
fiable test-the modified Kral procedure-which assesses continued movem
ent by the patient after cessation of passive movement was also admini
stered for comparison with facilitory paratonia. To assess frontal lob
e function, subjects were tested for echopraxia, distractibility, and
word fluency. To screen for other cognitive defects, subjects were giv
en the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE). Results The modified Kral
. procedure strongly correlated with subjective rating of facilitory p
aratonia. This correlation was significantly stronger than the correla
tion with oppositional paratonia. The modified Kral procedure was also
highly predictive of echopraxia, but was less predictive of other fro
ntal lobe tests. Facilitory paratonia, oppositional paratonia, and the
modified Kral procedure each strongly predicted scores on the MMSE. C
onclusions: Both facilitory and oppositional paratonia strongly predic
t general cognitive performance. The modified Kral procedure is a reli
able indicator of facilitory paratonia and a predictor of impaired per
formance on frontal lobe tests.