This paper integrates union bargaining into an efficiency model with i
mperfect monitoring of worker performance. The model is used to examin
e the effects of an increase in the benefit replacement ratio on wages
, employment, and effort. It is shown that, in contrast to both standa
rd shirking and trade union models, these effects are all ambiguous. I
n particular, if unions have some bargaining strength, a higher replac
ement ratio may reduce wages and increase employment Whenever employme
nt is increased the level of effort falls.