D. Curtin et al., ESTIMATING CALCIUM-MAGNESINM SELECTIVITY IN SMECTITIC SOILS FROM ORGANIC-MATTER AND TEXTURE, Soil Science Society of America journal, 62(5), 1998, pp. 1280-1285
Selectivity coefficients are essential to describe the distribution of
cations between the exchange and solution phases of soil. Because the
factors influencing Ca-Mg exchange have not been adequately defined,
models commonly incorporate the dubious assumption that soils do not d
iscriminate between these two cations (i.e., the selectivity coefficie
nt is 1). The purpose of this study was to identify key variables infl
uencing Ca-Mg selectivity in smectite-dominated soils of the Canadian
prairies. Selectivity coefficients (K) were measured by reacting soils
that differed in texture (50-500 g clay kg(-1)), organic matter (4-96
g C kg(-1)), and pH (4.1-7.3) with solutions containing mixtures of C
aCl2 and MgCl2. The value of K for the reaction Ca + Mg-soil reversibl
e arrow Mg + Ca-soil ranged from 1.1 to 3.4, depending on soil type an
d the composition of the reacting solution. Preference for Ca increase
d as the equivalent fraction of Ca in solution decreased from 0.8 (ave
rage K = 1.7) to 0.05 (average K = 2.9). We identified organic: matter
as the major source of Ca-preferring sites. The ratio of organic matt
er to clay was the best single indicator of Ca-Mg selectivity. Measure
ments on soils whose pH had been altered by laboratory addition of Ca(
OH)(2) or field application of anhydrous NH3 indicated that selectivit
y was independent of pH even though the proportion of organic sites in
creased as pH increased. A simple two-site model with K of 3.9 for org
anic matter and K of 1.3 for clay described our data reasonably well,
although selectivity for Ca tended to be underpredicted at low Ca load
ing.