Db. Jeffe et al., DOES CLINICAL-EXPERIENCE AFFECT MEDICAL, STUDENTS KNOWLEDGE, ATTITUDES, AND COMPLIANCE WITH UNIVERSAL PRECAUTIONS, Infection control and hospital epidemiology, 19(10), 1998, pp. 767-771
OBJECTIVE: To investigate differences in second-, third-, and fourth-y
ear medical students' knowledge of bloodborne pathogen exposure risks,
as well as their attitudes toward, and intentions to comply with, Uni
versal Precautions (UP).DESIGN: Cross-sectional survey. PARTICIPANTS A
ND SETTING: Surveys about students' knowledge, attitudes, and intentio
ns to comply with UP were completed by 111 second-year (preclinical),
80 third-year, and 60 fourth-year medical students at Washington Unive
rsity School of Medicine in the spring of 1996. RESULTS: Preclinical s
tudents knew more than clinical students about the efficacy of hepatit
is B vaccine, use of antiretroviral therapy after occupational exposur
e to human immunodeficiency virus, and nonvaccinated healthcare worker
s' risk of infection from needlestick injuries (P<.001). Students' per
ceived risk of occupational exposure to bloodborne pathogens and attit
udes toward hepatitis B vaccine did not differ, but preclinical studen
ts agreed more strongly that they should double glove for all invasive
procedures with sharps (P<.001). Clinical students agreed more strong
ly with reporting only high-risk needlestick injuries (P=.057) and wit
h rationalizations against using UP (P=.008). Preclinical students mor
e frequently reported contemplating or preparing to comply with double
gloving, wearing protective eyewear, reporting all exposures, and saf
ely disposing of sharps, whereas students with clinical experience wer
e more likely to report compliance. Clinical students also were more l
ikely to report having ''no plans'' to practice the first three of the
se precautions (P<.001). CONCLUSIONS: Differences in knowledge, attitu
des, and intentions to comply with UP between students with and withou
t clinical experience may have important implications for the timing a
nd content of interventions designed to improve compliance with UP (In
fect Control Hosp Epidemiol 1998;19:767-771).