Theoretical arguments have been developed that the shapes of lipid dom
ains at the air-water interface can be understood in terms of a compet
ition between line tension and long-range electrostatic forces. These
electrostatic forces can be approximated by effective dipoles, that is
, the differences in dipole densities mu in coexisting phases. Recent
experimental work has given quantitative confirmation that the long-ra
nge electrostatic forces can be expressed in terms of these dipoles. T
he present work further tests the theory of domain shapes involving co
mpetition between line tension and dipolar forces by observations of t
ransitions of circular domains to domains of lower symmetry. These tra
nsitions occur when the electrostatic repulsive forces exceed the forc
es of line tension lambda. Transitions of circular domains to domains
with shapes of lower symmetry are functions of domain radius and the d
imensionless parameter lambda/mu2; the experimental results are in acc
ord with theory to within the experimental error.