Acidity and basicity scales for polar solvents are examined and compar
ed with the mean spherical approximation parameters derived from the G
ibbs energy of solvation of the alkali metal and halide ions in 18 pol
ar solvents, both protic and aprotic. On the basis of an analysis of d
ata for the Gibbs energy of transfer of 1-1 electrolytes and standard
redox potentials for simple reactions in a variety of these solvents,
it is concluded that the most appropriate scales are the acceptor numb
er AN and donor number DN introduced by Gutmann. The extrathermodynami
c assumption for separating cationic and anionic contributions to ther
modynamic quantities for electrolytes based on equal solvation of the
tetraphenylarsonium and tetraphenylborate ions is reexamined. This ass
umption appears to be valid in aprotic solvents but questionable for p
rotic ones.