J. Chataway et al., THE GENETICS OF MULTIPLE-SCLEROSIS - PRINCIPLES, BACKGROUND AND UPDATED RESULTS OF THE UNITED-KINGDOM SYSTEMATIC GENOME SCREEN, Brain (Print), 121, 1998, pp. 1869-1887
Genetic susceptibility to multiple sclerosis is implicated on the basi
s of classical family studies and phenotype analyses. The only reprodu
cible legacy from the candidate gene approach has been the discovery o
f population associations with alleles of the major histocompatibility
complex; Systematic genome scanning has since been applied using a pa
nel of anonymous markers to identify areas of linkage in co-affected s
iblings. Here, we describe the principles of genome screening and upda
te the UK survey of multiple sclerosis. This identified 20 regions of
potential interest, but in none was there unequivocal linkage. In theo
ry, attempting to replicate these findings in a second set of sibling
pair families is the most appropriate way to distinguish true from fal
se positives, but unfortunately the number of families required to do
this reliably is prohibitively large. We used three approaches to incr
ease the definition achieved by the screen: (i) the number of sibling
pairs typed in an identified region of potential linkage was extended;
(ii) the information extraction was increased in an identified region
; and (iii) a search was made for missed regions of potential linkage.
Each of these approaches has considerable limitations. A chromosome-b
y-chromosome account is given to direct future searches. Although an a
dditional marker placed distal to the 'hit' on chromosome 14q increase
d linkage in this area, and typing extra sibling pairs increased linka
ge on chromosomes 6p and 17q, evidence for linkage was more commonly r
educed and no additional regions of interest were found. A further ref
inement of the genome screen was undertaken by conditioning for the pr
esence of HLA-DR15. This produced a surprising degree of segregation a
mong the regions of interest, which divided into two distinct groups d
epending on DR15 sharing: the DR15-sharing cohort comprised loci on ch
romosomal areas Ip, 17q and X; and the DR15-non-sharing cohort was mad
e up of loci on 1cen, 3p, 7p, 14q and 22q. This result further highlig
hts the genetic complexity of multiple sclerosis. What can now be infe
rred is that a gene of major effect is excluded from 95% of the genome
and one with a moderate role from 65%, whereas genes which make a ver
y small biological contribution cannot be discounted from any region.
The available results suggest that multiple sclerosis depends on indep
endent or epistatic effects of several genes each with small individua
l effects, rather than a very few genes of major biological importance
.