C. Beaudoin et al., CLINICAL TEACHERS AS HUMANISTIC CAREGIVERS AND EDUCATORS - PERCEPTIONS OF SENIOR CLERKS AND 2ND-YEAR RESIDENTS, CMAJ. Canadian Medical Association journal, 159(7), 1998, pp. 765-769
Background: The acquisition and nurturing of humanistic skills and att
itudes constitute an important aim of medical education. In order to a
ssess how conductive the physician-learning environment is to the acqu
isition of these skills, the authors determined the extent to which cl
inical teachers are perceived by their trainees, as humanistic with pa
tients and students, and they explored whether undergraduate and gradu
ate students share the same perceptions. Methods: A mail survey was co
nducted in 1994/95 of all senior clerks and second-year residents at L
aval University, University of Montreal and University of Sherbrooke m
edical schools. Of 774 trainees, 259 senior clerks and 238 second-year
residents returned the questionnaire, for an overall response rate of
64%. Students' perceptions of their teachers were measured on a 6-poi
nt Likert scale applied to statements about teachers' attitudes toward
the patient (5 items) and toward the student (5 items). Results: On a
verage, only 46% of the senior clerks agreed that their teachers displ
ayed the humanistic characteristics of interest. They were especially
critical of their teachers' apparent lack of sensitivity, with as many
as 3 out of 4 declaring that their teachers seemed to be unconcerned
about how patients adapt psychologically to their illnesses (75% of cl
erks) and that their teachers did not try to understand students' diff
iculties (78%) or to support students who have difficulties (77%). Com
pared with the clerks, the second-year residents were significantly le
ss critical, those with negative perceptions varying from 27% to 58%,
40% on average. Except for this difference, their pattern of responses
from one item to another was similar. Interpretation: This study sugg
ests the existence of a substantial gap between what medical trainees
are expected to learn and what they actually experience over the cours
e of their training. Because such a gap could represent a significant
barrier to the acquisition of important skills, more and urgent resear
ch is needed to understand better the factors influencing students' pe
rceptions.