Aizenman suggests that highly indebted countries' (HICs') credit marke
t policies should aim at increasing the degree of trade openness, sinc
e in the social optimum openness is larger than in the competitive mar
ket outcome. In this paper I show that when it is costly for creditors
to impose sanctions on a defaulting country, there is a penalty struc
ture alternative to Aizenman's which will be preferred by creditors. A
izenman's results on debtor's optimal openness and credit market polic
ies may then be reversed. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. JEL classific
ation: G1.