Ea. Tovar et al., MUSCLE-SPARING MINITHORACOTOMY WITH INTERCOSTAL NERVE CRYOANALGESIA -AN IMPROVED METHOD FOR MAJOR LUNG RESECTIONS, The American surgeon, 64(11), 1998, pp. 1109-1115
To decrease incisional pain, morbidity, and length of hospital stay (L
OS) and, hopefully, to reduce costs, most surgical specialties have tu
rned to minimally invasive procedures to access the body cavities duri
ng commonly performed operations. Video-assisted thoracic surgery (VAT
S) has emerged as the standard approach for a number of diagnostic and
therapeutic procedures in thoracic surgery. Major lung resections (lo
bectomy, bilobectomy, and pneumonectomy), however, can be performed th
rough an incision similar in size to the utility or access thoracotomy
used in VATS to remove the specimen. The purpose of this study was to
compare an oblique muscle-sparing minithoracotomy with intercostal ne
rve cryoanalgesia with the standard posterolateral thoracotomy incisio
n and VATS to perform major lung resections. Forty consecutive patient
s with bronchogenic carcinoma, operated on by a single surgeon, were c
hronologically divided into two groups, each with equivalent age, sex
distribution, physiologic parameters, tumor size, and clinical stage.
In addition, data were collected from a MEDLINE search of all publishe
d studies in which major lung resections were performed via VATS. The
first group (group A, n = 20) underwent posterolateral thoracotomy to
access the chest cavity, whereas the patients in the second group (gro
up B, n = 20) underwent oblique minithoracotomy with intercostal nerve
cryoanalgesia. Group B compared favorably with group A in LOS (P = 0.
002), narcotic requirements (P = 0.001), morbidity (P = 0.042), and co
st (P = 0.058). Group B also compared favorably with VATS major lung r
esection published data regarding LOS and morbidity.