G. Hummer et al., MOLECULAR THEORIES AND SIMULATION OF IONS AND POLAR-MOLECULES IN WATER, The journal of physical chemistry. A, Molecules, spectroscopy, kinetics, environment, & general theory, 102(41), 1998, pp. 7885-7895
Recent developments in molecular theories and simulation of ions and p
olar molecules in water are reviewed. The hydration of imidazole and i
midazolium is used to exemplify the theoretical issues. The treatment
of long-ranged electrostatic interactions in simulations is discussed
extensively. It is argued that the Ewald approach is an easy way to ge
t correct hydration free energies corresponding to thermodynamic limit
from molecular calculations. Molecular simulations with Ewald interac
tions and periodic boundary conditions can also be more efficient than
many common alternatives. The Ewald treatment permits a conclusive ex
trapolation to infinite system size. Accurate results for well-defined
models have permitted careful testing of simple theories of electrost
atic hydration free energies, such as dielectric continuum models. The
picture that emerges from such testing is that the most prominent fai
lings of the simplest theories are associated with solvent proton conf
ormations that lead to non-Gaussian fluctuations of electrostatic pote
ntials. Thus, the most favorable cases for second-order perturbation t
heories are monoatomic positive ions. For polar and anionic solutes, c
ontinuum or Gaussian theories are less accurate. The appreciation of t
he specific deficiencies of those simple models have led to new concep
ts, multistate Gaussian and quasi-chemical theories, which address the
cases for which the simpler theories fail. It is argued that, relativ
e to direct dielectric continuum treatments, the quasi-chemical theori
es provide a better theoretical organization for the computational stu
dy of the electronic structure of solution species.