P. Zurn et Jp. Danthine, ECONOMIC-EVALUATION OF DIFFERENT VACCINATION STRATEGIES AGAINST HEPATITIS-B IN SWITZERLAND, Sozial- und Praventivmedizin, 43, 1998, pp. 61-64
The aim of this study was to assets and compare the costs and epidemio
logical impact of different vaccination strategies against hepatitis B
in Switzerland, A birth cohort of 85000 individuals was followed over
its lifetime using a decision tree analysis. Published data were used
to simulate the risk of hepatitis B virus (HBV) infection in the coho
rt, the consecutive clinical outcomes and the associated costs, Five v
accination scenarios were assessed and compared to the baseline, defin
ed as the high-risk group strategy without prenatal screening. These w
ere: 1. systematic prenatal screening and vaccination of newborns at r
isk; 2. universal vaccination of infants; 3. universal vaccination of
schoolchildren; 4. universal vaccination of infants and schoolchildren
; 5. universal vaccination of infants schoolchildren and adolescents,
Results are presented using a 3% annual discounting rare. Systematic p
renatal screening reduced the number of chronic infections by 11% and
prevented 6 deaths per year. The cost per year of life saved was estim
ated to be 23 350 CHF. The four universal vaccination scenarios had a
much larger impact on the number of chronic infections and deaths prev
ented (reduction of 68-78%). Costs per year of life saved for universa
l vaccination ranged from 8820 CHF (infant strategy) to 12380 CHF (sch
oolchildren strategy). However; the vaccination of schoolchildren woul
d be as cost-effective as the vaccination of infants using alternative
assumptions (a lower compliance far infants compared to schoolchildre
n or the need for a booster later in life for infants). The benefit-co
st ratio ranged from 1.2 (systematic prenatal screening and vaccinatio
n of newborns at risk) to 2.9 (vaccination of infants). Universal vacc
ination against hepatitis B is more cost-effective than the current se
lective vaccination strategy of newborns.