Rj. Carsky et al., MAIZE YIELD DETERMINANTS IN FARMER-MANAGED TRIALS IN THE NIGERIAN NORTHERN GUINEA-SAVANNA, Experimental Agriculture, 34(4), 1998, pp. 407-422
Farmer-managed tests of Striga hermonthica-resistant maize varieties w
ere conducted in 1994 in a moderately intensified zone in the northern
Guinea savanna of Nigeria. Field history, soil properties, current se
ason fertility management, and crop management observations were recor
ded for 37 farmer-managed trials. Site averages for maize grain yield
varied from 300 to 4000 kg grain ha(-1) In spite of the tremendous var
iability observed, the grain yield was significantly higher for the st
riga-resistant hybrid 8321-18 compared with an improved open-pollinate
d variety, STR Syn-W, and the farmers' current variety. Correlation an
alysis and stepwise regression analysis of grain yield on measured var
iables suggested that maize yield was a function of plant density for
all three varieties. The rate of nitrogen fertilizer application was a
n important variable only for the hybrid, while the day of first weedi
ng was most important for the improved varieties. The yield of the loc
al varieties and STR Syn-W was related to the number of emerged striga
at harvest in the stepwise regression, and the yield of the local var
ieties was highly correlated with the striga-damage score on maize. Th
e striga-damage score was significantly lower on 8321-18 than on the o
ther varieties, suggesting some degree of resistance in the hybrid. Th
e number of emerged striga was lower for the hybrid but not significan
tly different. Farmers were almost unanimous in ranking the hybrid as
least damaged by striga and highest yielding. Besides being related to
maize variety, striga-damage score was lower if crop residue was obse
rved on the field at the time of site confirmation. Highest yields (ap
proximately 4 t ha(-1)) were recorded on fields near the homestead (co
mpound fields) where soil organic carbon values were 2.0-2.5%. Realiza
tion of maize yield potential in the absence of manure or fertilizer w
ill only be possible on long-term compound fields. Striga-resistant ma
ize can maintain high yields under S. hermonthica infestation.