A. Hilbeck et al., TOXICITY OF BACILLUS-THURINGIENSIS CRY1AB TOXIN TO THE PREDATOR CHRYSOPERLA-CARNEA (NEUROPTERA, CHRYSOPIDAE), Environmental entomology, 27(5), 1998, pp. 1255-1263
Laboratory feeding studies were carried out to determine the effects o
f the Bacillus thuringiensis (Berliner) Cry1Ab toxin on developmental
time and mortality of Chrysoperla carnea (Stephens) larvae. A bioassay
technique was developed that allowed for incorporation of the Cry1Ab
toxin into a liquid diet that was then encapsulated within small paraf
fin spheres. Because only 2nd and 3rd instars can penetrate the surfac
e of the paraffin spheres, 2 different methods were used to rear chrys
opid larvae through the Ist instar. The Ist method used small foam cub
es soaked in non-encapsulated, liquid diet (with or without Cry1Ab). T
he 2nd method used Ephestia kuehniella (Hubner) eggs as prey during th
e first instar (no Cry1Ab exposure). After reaching the 2nd instar, al
l larvae received encapsulated, artificial diet with or without Cry1Ab
, respectively. When reared only on artificial diet containing Cry1Ab
toxin, total immature mortality was significantly higher (57%) than in
the respective untreated control (30%). Also, significantly more chry
sopid larvae died (29%) that received Cry1Ab later during their larval
development compared with the respective control (17%). Although mort
ality was consistently higher, no or only small differences in develop
mental times were observed between Cry1Ab-treated and untreated C. car
nea larvae. C, carnea larvae required significantly more time to compl
ete larval development when reared on artificial diet only than when r
eared first on E. kuehniella eggs followed by encapsulated artifical d
iet or on only E. kuehniella eggs, regardless of exposure to Cry1Ab. T
hese results demonstrate that Cry1Ab is toxic to C. carnea at 100 mu m
g/ml of diet by using encapsulated artificial diet.