Lc. Davies et Rs. Mckelvey, EMOTIONAL AND BEHAVIORAL-PROBLEMS AND COMPETENCES AMONG IMMIGRANT ANDNON-IMMIGRANT ADOLESCENTS, Australian and New Zealand journal of psychiatry (Print), 32(5), 1998, pp. 658-665
Objective: The aim of this study was to compare levels of emotional an
d behavioural problems and competencies among immigrant and non-immigr
ant adolescents, and to determine factors that may contribute to any d
ifferences reported. Method: Subjects were selected randomly from stud
ents aged 12-16 years attending a high school with a high proportion o
f immigrants in Perth, Western Australia. Parents completed the Child
Behaviour Checklist (CBCL), and students completed the Youth Self-Repo
rt (YSR) and a Personal History Questionnaire. Results: On univariate
analyses, non-immigrant adolescents had significantly higher CBCL and
YSR scores than immigrant adolescents. Multivariate analyses suggested
that CBCL scores were predicted by a number of variables other than i
mmigration, including family intactness, socioeconomic status (SES) an
d gender. Higher YSR scores were predicted by non-intact families, sch
ool setting and non-immigrant status, and higher competencies scores w
ere predicted by higher SES and parents not being immigrants. Conclusi
ons: In assessing the effects of immigration on adolescent mental heal
th, it is important to control for factors associated with adolescent
behavioural and emotional problems and to use multiple informants. Ove
rall, immigrant adolescents report fewer total and externalising probl
ems and fewer competencies than native-born adolescents. This finding
may reflect strict immigration policies or cultural differences in def
initions of psychopathology and the social expectations for adolescent
s' behaviour.