Vr. Kanneganti et al., MODELING FREEZING-INJURY IN ALFALFA TO CALCULATE FORAGE YIELD - II - MODEL VALIDATION AND EXAMPLE SIMULATIONS, Agronomy journal, 90(5), 1998, pp. 698-704
Freezing Injury can cause extensive yield loss in alfalfa (Medicago sa
tiva L.) exposed to severe winters in cold climates. Alfalfa models mu
st simulate freezing injury effects in a cumulative way, so that forag
e dry matter (DM) yield can be accurately calculated during multiple y
ears of a crop, A companion paper presents ALFACOLD, an alfalfa simula
tion model developed by integrating functions of cold tolerance, fall
dormancy, and freezing injury into the ALSIM 1 (Level 2) alfalfa model
. The ALFACOLD model calculates forage yield on a daily basis, while s
imulating freezing injury across multiple years of the same crop. The
objective of this study was to test the ALFACOLD model's ability to ca
lculate field-measured forage DM yield, The model was tested against m
easured forage yield from 39 cultivars seeded in two years and managed
under a ii-cut system far 3 yr after the seeding year at two sites in
Wisconsin. Averaged across the sites, cultivars, and years, the ALFAC
OLD model calculated annual forage DM yield to within 12% of the measu
red yield, compared with an error of 35% with the ALSIM model, A regre
ssion of field-measured yield of individual harvests (n = 874) on the
corresponding ALFACOLD calculated yield indicated that 70% of the meas
ured variability in forage yield was explained by the model, The avera
ge difference between measured and calculated DM yield for Harvests I,
L and 3 was <7%, but the model overcalculated fourth-cut yield by 38%
, Averaged across all sites, cultivars, Sears, and cuts, the ALFACOLD
model calculated yield with an average SD of 600 kg ha (1) cut (1).