K. Zgraggen et al., COMPLICATIONS OF LAPAROSCOPIC CHOLECYSTECTOMY IN SWITZERLAND - A PROSPECTIVE 3-YEAR STUDY OF 10,174 PATIENTS, Surgical endoscopy, 12(11), 1998, pp. 1303-1310
Background: We set out to analyze the technical aspects, intraoperativ
e complications, morbidity, and mortality of laparoscopic cholecystect
omy in a multi-institutional study representative of Switzerland. Meth
ods: Data were collected from 10,174 patients from 82 surgical service
s. A total of 353 different parameters per patient were included. Resu
lts: We found intraoperative complications in 34.4% of patients and ha
d a conversion rate of 8.2%. This rate was significantly increased in
patients with complicated cholelithiasis and in those with previous up
per-but not lower-abdominal surgery. In most cases, conversions to ope
n procedures were required because of technical difficulties due to in
flammatory changes and/or unclear anatomical findings at the time of o
peration. Bleeding was a common intraoperative complication, that sign
ificantly increased the risk of conversion. Patients with loss of gall
stones in the peritoneal cavity had increased rates of abscesses. The
rate of common bile duct injuries was 0.31%, but it decreased signific
antly as the laparoscopic experience of the surgeon increased. The rat
e of common bile duct injuries was not increased in patients with acut
e cholecystitis or in the 1.32% of patients undergoing laparoscopic co
mmon bile duct exploration. Intraoperative cholangiography did not red
uce the risk of common bile duct injuries, but it allowed them to be d
iagnosed intraoperatively in 75% of patients. Local complications were
recorded in 4.79% of patients, and systemic complications were seen i
n 5.59%. The mortality rate was 0.2%. Conclusions: Although laparoscop
ic cholecystectomy is a safe procedure, the rate of conversion to open
cholecystectomy is still substantial. The conversion rate depends bot
h on the indication and intraoperative complications. There is still a
10.38% morbidity associated with the procedure; however, the incidenc
e of common bile duct injuries, which decreases with growing laparosco
pic experience, was relatively low.