Results to date indicate that high-dose therapy (HDT) with autologous
stem cell support improves survival of patients with symptomatic multi
ple myeloma (MM). We performed a multicenter, sequential, randomized t
rial designed to assess the optimal timing of HDT and autotransplantat
ion. Among 202 enrolled patients who were up to 56 years old, 185 were
randomly assigned to receive HDT and peripheral blood stem cell (PBSC
) autotransplantation (early HDT group, n = 91) or a conventional-dose
chemotherapy (CCT) regimen (late HDT group, n = 94). In the late HDT
group, HDT and transplantation were performed as rescue treament, in c
ase of primary resistance to CCT or at relapse in responders. PBSC wer
e collected before randomization, after mobilization by chemotherapy,
and, in the two groups, HDT was preceded by three or four treatments w
ith vincristine, doxorubicin, and methylprednisolone. Data were analyz
ed on an intent-to-treat basis using a sequential design. Within a med
ian follow-up of 58 months, estimated median overall survival (OS) was
64.6 months in the early HDT group and 64 months in the rate group. S
urvival curves were not different (P = .92, log-rank test). Median eve
nt-free survival (EFS) was 39 months in the early HDT group whereas me
dian time between randomization and CCT failure was 13 months in the l
ate group. Average time without symptoms, treatment, and treatment tox
icity (TWISTT) were 27.8 months (95% confidence interval [Cl]; range,
23.8 to 31.8) and 22.3 months (range, 16.0 to 28.6) in the two groups,
respectively. HDT with PBSC transplantation obtained a median OS exce
eding 5 years in young patients with symptomatic MM, whether performed
early, as first-line therapy, or late, as rescue treatment. Early HDT
may be preferred because it is associated with a shorter period of ch
emotherapy. (C) 1998 by The American Society of Hematology.