We calculate the deep-inelastic response of superfluid He-4 and normal
He-3. Following the Monte Carlo scheme of Carraro and Koonin, we repr
esent the final-state effects by sampling the one-dimensional scatteri
ng wave function of the recoiling atom in a static background. We perf
orm diffusion Monte Carlo simulations, using optimized trial functions
and adopting the fixed node approximation for He-3. For He-4 the agre
ement with recent high-precision measurements is excellent, whereas in
the case of He-3 a small but not negligible discrepancy with availabl
e experimental information exists. Possible biases in the calculation
are discussed, but the question remains open. This is not the first in
stance where some inconsistency is found between theoretical calculati
ons and the analysis of neutron-scattering data for He-3. We have also
considered two very different fermion wave functions, yielding either
a discontinuous or a continuous momentum distribution. They give hard
ly distinguishable results for the response, ruling out the possibilit
y of detecting the discontinuity by deep-inelastic neutron scattering
at the present level of experimental accuracy. [S0163-1829(98)08038-2]
.