P. Hopwood et al., PSYCHOLOGICAL SUPPORT NEEDS FOR WOMEN AT HIGH GENETIC RISK OF BREAST-CANCER - SOME PRELIMINARY INDICATORS, Psycho-oncology (Chichester), 7(5), 1998, pp. 402-412
The number of women in the UK seeking genetic counselling, testing and
preventative treatment is rapidly increasing. In Manchester 600-800 w
omen are now referred annually to the Family History Clinic. As yet th
ere is no formal provision for this service within the NHS, but resear
ch is underway to evaluate such clinics and to identify the psychosoci
al sequelae of genetic risk counselling. To date, findings have been b
ased on questionnaire data from which it is difficult to ascertain sup
port needs accurately. We interviewed 158 women 3 months after genetic
risk counselling because of a family history of breast cancer. Using
standard assessment and diagnostic criteria, 21 (13%) women were diagn
osed with an affective disorder. This compared with a prevalence of 26
% using the 28 item General Health Questionnaire (GHQ).We did not find
a relationship between GHQ distress levels and women's understanding
of their risk before genetic counselling, but women with accurate risk
knowledge post-counsel had significantly lower GHQ scores than those
who continued to over or under-estimate and this Finding warrants furt
her investigation. Of women referred for psychological help, few repor
ted risk of breast cancer as their main concern, but themes of loss, u
nresolved grief and relationship problems were common. The value of th
e GHQ as a screening instrument is discussed and we suggest a new thre
shold Value based on our analysis. We conclude that risk counselling d
oes not adversely affect the general mental health of attenders but a
minority of women may need help with the impact of breast cancer in th
e family. (C) 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.