SYNERGISM BETWEEN NATURAL ENEMIES AND BIOPESTICIDES - A TEST-CASE USING THE STINKBUG PERILLUS-BIOCULATUS (HEMIPTERA, PENTATOMIDAE) AND BACILLUS-THURINGIENSIS-TENEBRIONIS AGAINST COLORADO POTATO BEETLE (COLEOPTERA, CHRYSOMELIDAE)
C. Cloutier et C. Jean, SYNERGISM BETWEEN NATURAL ENEMIES AND BIOPESTICIDES - A TEST-CASE USING THE STINKBUG PERILLUS-BIOCULATUS (HEMIPTERA, PENTATOMIDAE) AND BACILLUS-THURINGIENSIS-TENEBRIONIS AGAINST COLORADO POTATO BEETLE (COLEOPTERA, CHRYSOMELIDAE), Journal of economic entomology, 91(5), 1998, pp. 1096-1108
Sublethal effects of Bacillus thuringiensis on pests could synergize w
ith natural enemies through extended larval development and reduced de
fense against predators. Mortality ranged from 18 to 76% for 4th insta
r Colorado potato beetles feeding on potato foliage dipped in M-Trak a
t 0.2-3.2 ml/liter H2O. Survivors resumed feeding: in 48 h, but feedin
g was prolonged and time to pupation was extended 33-46%. Predation su
ccess by small nymphs of Perillus bioculatus was 40-77% on 4th instar
potato beetle larvae that survived M-Trak exposure compared to only 3-
40% on healthy lih instars. Thus, susceptibility to predation as well
as extended development of larvae constitute mechanisms Ly which B. t.
tenebrionis could synergize with predators in increasing mortality. T
his prediction was tested in 1994-1995 using field releases of P. bioc
ulatus followed by applications of low doses of B. t. tenebrionis. At
rates of 1-4 per plant in both years, P, bioculatus destroyed 17-55% o
f potato beetle eggs compared to 1.6-4.9% in control plots. In 1994, p
otato beetle larval mortality could not be related to rates of either
control or their combination due to early P. bioculatus dispersal at l
ow larval prey density. However, interaction between P, bioculatus and
B. I tenebrionis was significant in 1995 in combinations of P. biocul
atus (1-2 per plant) and Novodor (2 liters/ha). the interactive effect
causing 31% more larval mortality than expected from simple additive
effects. The 2-yr field results indicate that synergism of B, thuringi
ensis with the egg-larval predator P. bioculatus in killing potato bee
tle larvae would critically depend on enough beetle eggs escaping pred
ation to locally retain the predator during larval development.