One of the ubiquitous features of membrane proteins is the preference
of tryptophan and tyrosine residues for membrane surfaces that presuma
bly arises from enhanced stability due to distinct interfacial interac
tions. The physical basis for this preference is widely believed to ar
ise from amphipathic interactions related to imino group hydrogen bond
ing and/or dipole interactions. We have examined these and other possi
bilities for tryptophan's interfacial preference by using H-1 magic an
gle spinning (MAS) chemical shift measurements, two-dimensional (2D) n
uclear Overhauser effect spectroscopy (2D-NOESY) H-1 MAS NMR, and soli
d state H-2 NMR to study the-interactions of four tryptophan analogues
with phosphatidylcholine membranes. We find that the analogues reside
in the vicinity of the glycerol group where they all cause similar mo
dest changes in acyl chain organization and that hydrocarbon penetrati
on was not increased by reduction of hydrogen bonding or electric dipo
le interaction ability. These observations rule out simple amphipathic
or dipolar interactions as the physical basis for the interfacial pre
ference. More likely, the preference is dominated by tryptophan's flat
rigid shape that limits access to the hydrocarbon core and its pi ele
ctronic structure and associated quadrupolar moment (aromaticity) that
favor residing in the electrostatically complex interface environment
.