Carbon isotope effect studies were undertaken with the wild-type pyrid
oxal 5'-phosphate (PLP)dependent enzyme ornithine decarboxylase (ODC)
from Trypanosoma brucei and with several active site mutants of the en
zyme. For the decarboxylation of the optimal substrate, L-ornithine, b
y wild-type ODC, the observed carbon isotope effect (k(12)/k(13)) is 1
.033 at pH 7.3. In comparison to the expected intrinsic isotope effect
(k(12)/k(13) = 1.06) for decarboxylation, this value suggests that bo
th the rate of decarboxylation and the rate of Schiff base interchange
with L-ornithine are partially rate-limiting for the reaction steps u
p to decarboxylation. In contrast, with the alternate substrate L-Lys,
which shows lower catalytic efficiency, the carbon isotope effect inc
reased to 1.063, demonstrating that decarboxylation has become the rat
e limiting step. For the mutant enzymes, E274A ODC and C360A ODC, with
L-ornithine as substrate the carbon isotope effect also approaches th
e intrinsic limit. Glu-274 was previously demonstrated to play a direc
t role in carbanion stabilization, and thus the large carbon isotope e
ffect (k(12)/k(13) = 1.055) is consistent with an impaired rate of dec
arboxylation compared to wild-type ODC. In contrast, for K69A ODC, the
isotope effect is almost entirely suppressed, suggesting that Schiff-
base formation (which now must occur from enzyme-bound PLP, rather tha
n from an enzyme-bound PLP-Schiff base) has become rate-determining.