Ej. Gustafson, CLUSTERING TIMBER HARVESTS AND THE EFFECT OF DYNAMIC FOREST MANAGEMENT POLICY ON FOREST FRAGMENTATION, ECOSYSTEMS, 1(5), 1998, pp. 484-492
To integrate multiple uses (mature forest and commodity production) be
tter on forested lands, timber management strategies that cluster harv
ests have been proposed. One such approach clusters harvest activity i
n space and time, and rotates timber production zones across the lands
cape with a long temporal period (dynamic zoning). Dynamic zoning has
been shown to increase timber production and reduce forest fragmentati
on by segregating uses in time without reducing the spatial extent of
timber production. It is reasonable to wonder what the effect of perio
dic interruptions in the implementation of such as strategy might be,
as would be expected in a dynamic political environment. To answer the
se questions, I used a timber harvest simulation model (HARVEST) to si
mulate a dynamic zoning harvest strategy that was periodically interru
pted by changes in the spatial dispersion of harvests, by changes in t
imber production levels, or both. The temporal scale (period) of these
interruptions had impacts related to the rate at which the forest ach
ieved canopy closure after harvest. Spatial dynamics in harvest polici
es had a greater effect on the amount of forest interior and edge than
did dynamics in harvest intensity. The periodically clustered scenari
os always produced greater amounts of forest interior and less forest
edge than did their never clustered counterparts. The results suggest
that clustering of harvests produces less forest fragmentation than di
spersed cutting alternatives, even in the face of a dynamic policy fut
ure. Although periodic episodes of dispersed cutting increased fragmen
tation, average and maximum fragmentation measures were Less than if c
lustered harvest strategies were never implemented. Clustering may als
o be useful to mitigate the fragmentation effects of socially mandated
increases in timber harvest levels. Implementation of spatial cluster
ing during periods of high timber harvest rates reduced the variation
in forest interior and edge through time, providing a more stable supp
ly of forest interior habitat across the landscape.