Enhanced 5 year survival rates with adjuvant chemotherapy for colon an
d rectal cancers are 5% and 9% respectively, according to recent meta-
analysis. Despite the NM consensus statement endorsing adjuvant chemot
herapy, many clinicians regard such a seemingly small benefit not just
worthy of the expense, inconvenience, discomfort and risk of treatment
for their individual patient with colorectal carcinoma. The aim of th
is study is to evaluate these quality of life issues. The seven criter
ia considered most important were determined by interviews of treated
patients, who emphasized the following quality of life parameters: nau
sea and vomiting, diarrhea, perineal dermatitis, asthenia, impairment
of daily activity, family support, and difficulties of daily transport
ation to hospital. A numeric scale (1-5) was used to measure their ans
wers (0 = hospitalization, 5 = no modification), and the nonparametric
rank coefficient of Kendall was used to compare them. Twenty patients
with colon cancer treated with Moertel's protocol and 5 patients with
rectal cancer treated with Krook's protocol were evaluated. The study
revealed a diminished quality of life for both patients with colon ca
ncer (7 on a scale of 10) and those with rectal cancer (6 on the same
scale). By using the same questionnaire at one week interval, the resp
onses remained unchanged (p < 0.001). The effect of radiotherapy seems
to be responsible for this difference. This study is one of the first
to approach the quality of life from the real interested party's poin
t of view : the patient.