In a recent study, the angular anisotropy of the intermolecular potent
ial of the He-NH4+ ionic complex has been estimated using ab initio me
thods, In response, Read and Buckingham have calculated the anisotropi
c contributions arising from long-range induction and dispersion inter
actions and have found near quantitative agreement with the ab initio
computations for the energy difference between the vertex-bound and fa
ce-bound minima, Thus encouraged, they have predicted minimum structur
es for Rg-NH4+ complexes involving heavier rare gas (Rg) atoms and hav
e concluded that the face-bound structure becomes more favorable as th
e size of the rare gas atom increases, However as discussed here, ab i
nitio results for Ar-NH4+ differ from their predictions.