The rare preservation of columns perpendicular to bedding may provide
convincing evidence that ancient crinoids adopted an upright attitude
during life. However, taphonomic and sedimentological analyses are imp
ortant in determining whether such occurrences are truly in situ or re
present unusual allochthonous accumulations. The Crinoid Biosome of th
e Thornton Reef Complex, Silurian of Illinois, USA, includes pluricolu
mnals preserved perpendicular to bedding, in association with more com
mon specimens parallel or angled to bedding. Upright pluricolumnals ar
e relatively shorter (<150 mm) than the longest non-upright specimens;
they sometimes occur as imbricate accumulations and lack attachment s
tructures (although these are preserved separately). Brachiopod valves
and colonial corals may also be preserved perpendicular to bedding. T
hese features suggest that the Thornton beds were formed as viscous ma
ss flow deposits and that the upright crinoid columns are allochthonou
s or, at best, parautochthonous. (C) 1996 by John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.