The social and material lives of African Americans on antebellum plant
ations in the southern United States were heavily influenced by power
relations inherent to the institution of slavery. Although planters ex
erted immense control over slaves, plantation slavery involved constan
t negotiation between master and slave. This give-and-take was part of
the lived experience of enslaved African Americans, and one way to ap
proach the study of this experience is by adopting a dialectical view
of power. I illustrate how such a theoretical approach can be employed
by examining the archaeology of slavery at the Hermitage plantation,
located near Nashville, Tennessee. By examining material culture from
former slave cabins located on different parts of the plantation, I ex
plore how various categories of material culture reflected and partici
pated in planters' efforts to control slaves, as well as how those eff
orts were contested.