Background: Most patients with osteoarthritis (OA) are treated by prim
ary care physicians (in this article, primary care physicians are fami
ly physicians and general internists). Objective: To describe and comp
are the self-reported practice patterns of family physicians and gener
al internists for the evaluation and management of severe OA of the kn
ee, including factors that might influence referral for total knee rep
lacement. Design, getting, and Participants: A survey was developed an
d mailed to randomly selected community family physicians and general
internists practicing in Indiana. Main Outcome Measurer Self-reported
physician practice patterns regarding OA of the knee. Results: Physica
l examination was the most common method of evaluating OA of the knee.
Family physicians were more likely to examine for crepitation, joint
stability, and quadriceps muscle strength than were general internists
(P<.05). Patients with OA of the knee treated by family physicians we
re more likely to receive nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs or oral
corticosteroids and were less likely to receive aspirin, acetaminophe
n, or narcotics compared with patients treated by general internists.
Six patient characteristics were rated as positive factors favoring a
referral for possible total knee replacement, 8 characteristics were r
ated as negative, and 5 were rated as not a factor in the decision abo
ut referral. Conclusions: Results from this study suggest that additio
nal research is needed to determine the evaluative techniques for OA o
f the knee that provide the most useful information for management dec
isions, the management techniques that maximize patient outcomes, and
the criteria that should be used to select patients who would benefit
most from referral for possible total knee replacement.