We explored identity disturbance and some of its correlates and antece
dents in patients with personality disorder (PD) pathology. A group of
inpatients who all were diagnosed as PD on self-reports were divided
as those with (28 patients) and without (62 patients) identity disturb
ance on the basis of the DSM-III-R borderline PD identity item criteri
on. The division of the patients was tested and found to be valid. Bot
h groups were compared with each other. Seventy-five percent of patien
ts with and 34% of patients without identity disturbance received the
definite interview diagnosis of PD. The syndrome of identity disturban
ce was encountered in basically all PD types. In contrast. half of all
patients with PD presented no identity disturbance. Identity disturba
nce did not predispose to specific axis I disorders and suicidal behav
ior, and it was not correlated convincingly with childhood traumatic e
xperiences and parental bonding scores. The results neither support th
e DSM conceptualization of identity disturbance as an exclusive charac
teristic of borderline PD. nor the Kernberg's concept of identity dist
urbance as an essential of borderline personality organization which s
hould be found in almost all PD types. Copyright (C) 1998 by W.B. Saun
ders Company.