As. Pennanen et al., 2-YEAR FOLLOW-UP-STUDY OF NON REGULATORY RECOMMENDATIONS FOR BETTER AIR-QUALITY IN INDOOR ICE ARENAS, Environment international, 24(8), 1998, pp. 881-887
A standardized questionnaire was used in a two-year follow-up study to
test the effectiveness of non-regulatory recommendations to improve i
ndoor air quality of 103 ice arenas in Finland. In addition, the perfo
rmance of a state-of-the-art emission control technology (ECT) on prop
ane-fueled resurfacers was evaluated by measuring the one-week average
nitrogen dioxide (NO2) concentration in a small sample of arenas. The
number of retrofitted ECT on propane-fueled resurfacers increased fro
m 6 to 37 (8% to 37% of ice arenas) and the number of electric resurfa
cers from 7 to 9 (both 9% of arenas) in 1994-96. At the same time, the
prevalence of inadequate ventilation increased among the most suscept
ible small arenas (volume <30000 m(3)) from 11 (31%) to 19 (38%). Comb
ustion-powered resurfacers (88%) and inadequate ventilation (24%) were
prevalent also among the 17 new arenas built in 1994-96. ECT resurfac
ers significantly decreased the mean indoor NO2 concentration of eleve
n arenas from 650 mu g/m(3) to 147 mu g/m(3). Thus, retrofitting resur
facers with ECT seems to be a feasible mitigation option to improve in
door air quality in ice arenas, but the ultimate solution is an electr
ic ice resurfacer. Non-regulatory recommendations seem to be partially
effective in abatement against the air quality problems, but addition
al regulatory measures are needed for full compliance in all arenas. (
C) 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd.