D. Matthews et B. Dietzuhler, THE BLACK-SHEEP EFFECT - HOW POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE ADVERTISEMENTS AFFECT VOTERS PERCEPTIONS OF THE SPONSOR OF THE ADVERTISEMENT, Journal of applied social psychology, 28(20), 1998, pp. 1903-1915
Participants read a positive or negative (mock) political advertisemen
t that was sponsored by either an in-group (subject and sponsor were m
embers of the same political party) or an out-group (subject and spons
or were members of different political parties) member. The results fo
und support for a black-sheep effect. An in-group sponsor of a positiv
e advertisement was evaluated more positively than any out-group membe
r, regardless of advertisement type, or an in-group member who sponsor
ed a negative advertisement. However, an in-group sponsor of a negativ
e advertisement was evaluated more negatively than either an in-group
sponsor of a positive advertisement, or an out-group sponsor, regardle
ss of advertisement type. The results are discussed in terms of social
identity theory.