To interpret fracture of solids, an appropriate fracture criterion is
required. It is often believed that the level of strain ahead of a cra
ck tip controls the fracture event for materials exhibiting high ducti
lity, e.g. ductile fracture of A533B steel in the upper shelf regime.
And the level of stress ahead of a crack tip controls the brittle frac
ture event, e.g. cleavage fracture of A533B steel in the lower shelf r
egime. Within each regime (ductile or brittle), the level of constrain
t of a specimen or structure determines the magnitude of the apparent
fracture toughness. In this paper, we address the difference in the ef
fect of constraint on the stress- or strain-controlled fracture. It is
found that the constraint plays an opposite role to the apparent frac
ture toughness values for strain-controlled vs, stress-controlled frac
ture. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.