O. Richmond, DEVIOUS OBJECTIVES AND THE DISPUTANTS VIEW OF INTERNATIONAL MEDIATION- A THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK, Journal of peace research, 35(6), 1998, pp. 707-722
This article examines the process of international mediation from the
perspective of the disputants. It posits that contrary to standard ana
lyses, which tend to examine mediation from the perspective of the con
flict or the third parry, an examination from the point of view of the
disputants provides significant insights into mediation as a form of
conflict management From an inside-out perspective, it becomes apparen
t that the underlying assumption that a compromise solution is the obj
ective of the disputants involved in the mediation process is suspect.
Thus, disputants may become involved in a, mediation process in order
to improve upon their prospects, but not necessarily in terms of a co
mpromise with their adversary. This article argues that a mediation pr
ocess carries with it a series of assets that the disputants may value
in terms of their pre-negotiation objectives, rather than in terms of
the compromise that the previous debates about international mediatio
n have indicated. The disputants may therefore harbour 'devious object
ives', unrelated to the attainment of a compromise solution, which mig
ht include time to regroup and reorganize; internationalization; the s
earch for an ally; empowerment; legitimization of their negotiation po
sitions and current status; face saving; and avoiding costly concessio
ns by prolonging the process itself.