G. Ali et al., VITAMIN-B-12 DEFICIENCY - EARLY DIAGNOSIS IN THE AMBULATORY SETTING, Schweizerische medizinische Wochenschrift, 128(45), 1998, pp. 1763-1771
Many patients suffer from vitamin B-12 deficiency and are thus exposed
to irreversible sequelae if diagnosis occurs at a late stage. This pr
ospective study undertaken by eight practitioners over a period of 12
months concerns early diagnosis. Blood vitamin B-12 levels were measur
ed in 152 patients presenting macrocytosis detected by systematic MCV
analysis at the time of a blood test, a neuropathy or a recent cogniti
ve, affective and behavioural problem, and were found to be lowered (l
ess than or equal to 175 pmol/l) in 54 patients of whom 43 had undergo
ne vitamin B12 test treatment for 6 months. Haematological, neurologic
al and psychiatric evaluation was carried out before and after treatme
nt, and a diagnosis of deficiency was recorded in 24 patients based on
unequivocal response to therapy. Improvement was greatest haematologi
cally in 12 patients, neurologically in 6 patients and psychiatrically
in 6 other patients, with 4 patients showing a combination of all mod
es. These 24 patients (mean age 69 years) suffered from numerous patho
logies which were liable to complicate diagnosis in some of them: neur
ological (46%), psychiatric (37%), chronic alcoholism (33%), folic aci
d deficiency (29%), and diabetes (17%). The only diagnostic element us
ed as a criterion of deficiency was an extremely low level of vitamin
B-12 (less than or equal to 75 pmol/l). Marked macrocytosis or a combi
nation of haematological and neuropsychiatric signs are strong indicat
ors, but only improvement under treatment allowed a diagnosis to be ma
de in the majority of patients. Macrocytosis was, however, not present
in 6 of the 12 neuropsychiatric patients. The study thus identified a
high proportion of patients with vitamin B-12 deficiency who addition
ally presented, in equal proportions, both haematological and neuropsy
chiatric symptoms. Neither the clinical examination nor the vitamin B-
12 level in general permit early diagnosis based on a high probability
index and long-term follow-up. Simpler methods for early diagnosis ar
e therefore needed.