V. Speirs et al., SHORT-TERM PRIMARY CULTURE OF EPITHELIAL-CELLS DERIVED FROM HUMAN BREAST-TUMORS, British Journal of Cancer, 78(11), 1998, pp. 1421-1429
As experimental models for breast cancer, most studies rely on establi
shed human breast cancer cell lines. However, many of these lines were
established over 20 years ago, many from pleural effusions rather tha
n the primary tumour, so the validity of using them as representative
models is questionable. This paper describes our experiences, over a 3
-year period, in establishing short-term epithelial-cell-enriched prep
arations from primary breast tumours based on differential centrifugat
ion followed by culture in selective media. Epithelial cells were succ
essfully cultured from 55% of samples, but culture success did not app
ear to be correlated with tumour histology, stage, grade or node statu
s. Epithelial cell-enriched cultures were immunopositive for broad-spe
ctrum cytokeratin and epithelial membrane antigen (EMA). Positivity fo
r keratin 19 confirmed that the cultures contained tumour-derived cell
s, which additionally showed significantly higher activity of the redu
ctive pathway of the steroid-converting enzyme 17 beta-hydroxysteroid
dehydrogenase type I. That the cultures contained tumour and not norma
l epithelial cells was further substantiated by the complete absence o
f the calmodulin-like gene NB-l in tumour-derived cultures; this is on
ly associated with normal breast epithelia. Eighty-five per cent of cu
ltures established from oestrogen receptor (ER)-positive tumours expre
ssed ER in vitro; this was functional in 66% of cultures, although ER-
positive phenotype was gradually lost over time. In conclusion, epithe
lial cells can be isolated and maintained as short-term cultures from
primary breast tumours irrespective of histopathological or clinical d
etails, providing a model system with a greater biological and clinica
l relevance than breast cancer cell lines.