Dvm. Bishop et al., WHEN A NOD IS AS GOOD AS A WORD - FORM-FUNCTION RELATIONSHIPS BETWEENQUESTIONS AND THEIR RESPONSES, Applied psycholinguistics, 19(3), 1998, pp. 415-432
It is well established that syntactic form and communicative function
do not always correspond: for instance, a syntactic question might fun
ction as a request for information (''did you see the play?'') or a re
quest for acknowledgment when there is no doubt about polarity of the
response (''there's a tower at Blackpool, isn't there''). Using data f
rom a corpus of 18 child-adult conversations, we distinguished adult u
tterances that solicited information from those soliciting acknowledgm
ent (i.e., where the response was predictable, and the utterance serve
d a predominantly social function). Both types of utterance were usual
ly responded to by children, but the form of response differed accordi
ng to the communicative function of the utterance. Nonverbal and proso
dic responses (eg, nods or ''mmh'') were significantly more likely to
occur in response to utterances soliciting acknowledgment than in resp
onse to yes/no questions that solicited information. There were consis
tent form-function relationships for responses as well as for soliciti
ng utterances. Nonverbal nods and headshakes were not functionally equ
ivalent to verbal ''yes'' and ''no.''