Ra. David et M. Rhee, THE IMPACT OF LANGUAGE AS A BARRIER TO EFFECTIVE HEALTH-CARE IN AN UNDERSERVED URBAN HISPANIC COMMUNITY, The Mount Sinai journal of medicine, 65(5-6), 1998, pp. 393-397
Background: Language barriers between patient and physician impact upo
n effective health care. This phenomenon is not well studied in the li
terature. Methods: A survey was created in English and Spanish, and ad
ministered at the ambulatory site for medical housestaff and faculty a
t a teaching hospital. ''Cases'' were defined as patients who reported
using a translator or as having poor English skills. Patients who rep
orted not using a translator and having good English skills served as
controls. Both groups were predominantly of Hispanic origin. Results:
Analysis revealed 68 cases and 193 controls. The survey completion rat
e was 96%. The data were predominantly categorical. Chi-square analysi
s was utilized. Both groups responded that understanding medication si
de effects corresponds to compliance (87% cases vs 93% controls, p = 0
.18). More cases responded that side effects were not explained (47% v
s 16%, p < 0.001). More controls reported satisfaction with medical ca
re (93% vs 84%, p < 0.05). More controls agreed that their doctors und
erstood how they were feeling, with statistical significance in Hispan
ic subset analysis (87% vs 72%, p < 0.05). Both groups felt they had e
nough time to communicate with their doctors (89% vs 88%, p = 0.86). M
ore cases than controls reported having had a mammogram within the las
t 2 years (78% vs 60%, p < 0.05). Conclusions: Lack of explanation of
side effects to medication appeared to correlate negatively with compl
iance with medication. The language barrier correlated negatively with
patient satisfaction. Cases reported more preventive testing; test or
dering map replace dialogue.