We investigated whether plagiarism may occur inadvertently if one has
implicit-but not explicit-memory for previously seen material. We aske
d participants to produce material that was truly original, not just n
ovel in the present context. For some categories, participants read an
d generated real exemplars; for others they read and generated fictiti
ous exemplars. Participants then recalled the items they had generated
for each category and generated additional items. Although participan
ts inadvertently repeated real exemplars at an above chance rate, they
did not repeat the fictitious exemplars. Their failure to repeat the
fictitious exemplars was not due to a lack of implicit memory for thos
e items because significant repetition priming was obtained in a perce
ptual identification test. These results raise the possibility that in
advertent plagiarism rarely occurs when people attempt to produce trul
y original material.