This article presents a narrative, autoethnographic, theoretical accou
nt of the public and private negotiation of ''minor bodily stigmas,''
which are mild physical ''imperfections'' that make us fear we stand o
ut and might be rejected. To examine the situated complexity of stigma
tized identity, I tell a story that shows concrete interactional detai
ls of an episode in which minor bodily stigmas evolved into a signific
ant topic of conversation between strangers. My personal narrative exp
lores the felt experience of minor bodily stigmas from the perspective
of the experiencing and interacting holder. Thus, my work problematiz
es Erving Goffman's sociological approach to stigmas, which examines i
nclusively all forms of stigmas from a distanced observational stance
of beholder that privileges the outsider perspective of how others see
us. Using minor bodily stigmas as a heuristic category, I emphasize h
ow they are experienced as a double bind in interaction (to notice or
not to notice) and a double bind in personal feelings (of moral charac
ter as well as physical appearance). I seek to connect theoretical and
categorical understandings of minor bodily stigmas to their concrete
felt experience in day-to-day life in order to examine possibilities f
or resisting and reframing stigmas in everyday life.