Sr. Schuler et Z. Hossain, FAMILY-PLANNING CLINICS THROUGH WOMENS EYES AND VOICES - A CASE-STUDYFROM RURAL BANGLADESH, International family planning perspectives, 24(4), 1998, pp. 170
Context: The voices and views of clients are an essential, but often n
eglected aspect in initiatives to improve the quality of care provided
by family planning and reproductive health programs. Methods: In anti
cipation of an increased emphasis on clinic-based services in Banglade
sh's national family planning program, a small qualitative study was u
ndertaken in six villages in late 1996. In-depth interviews were condu
cted with 34 clients of six government and two nongovernment clinics,
and researchers spent one day at each clinic observing how providers a
nd clients interacted. Results: Hierarchical modes of interaction and
poor communication dominated many of the encounters, and women had to
beg for services in some clinics. Providers appeared to selectively ap
ply interpersonal skills and common courtesy; rudeness to clients was
not merely a reflection of ignorance, since the paramedics appeared to
know the basic principles of counseling. Limited access to medication
and often arbitrary ways of determining when to dispense if created s
uspicion and tension between providers and clients. Most clients expre
ssed a willingness to overlook rode treatment, long waits and unhygien
ic conditions, saying that because they were poor, they could not expe
ct better care and had no service alternatives. Conclusions: Technical
solutions, such as training in counseling, may not be enough to impro
ve the quality of care provided in clinics in rural Bangladesh. Instit
utional policies, norms and incentives need to become more client-orie
nted if the transition from in-home delivery to clinics is to be a suc
cess.