This paper is aimed at elucidating the cause of a series of malfunctio
ns involving the bending or breaking of main steam turbine throttle va
lve spindles which occurred at service times ranging from hundreds to
several thousand hours in a number of 270 MW steam raising units. It w
as clearly established, by two distinct approaches (one engineering, o
ne micromechanistic) that the stresses which produced these malfunctio
ns were bending in nature and were the result of out-of-alignment defl
ections. In the case of the bent spindles the stresses were Very high
and approached flow strength levels of around 8000 MPa while the broke
n spindles were the results of fatigue initiation and subsequent growt
h from a thread root (stress concentration) location on the spindle. U
sing relevant fatigue crack propagation data for the valve spindle mat
erial at 300 degrees C it was demonstrated that fatigue failures occur
red at spindle deflections of between 0.9 and 1.6 mm. Finally, it was
demonstrated that the fatigue breakage problem could be significantly
reduced, especially at the lower end of the valve spindle deflection r
ange, by a combination of re-profiling the thread root and shot peenin
g. (C) 1998 Published by Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.