G. Harisch et J. Dittmann, EXPERIMENTS FOR DETECTING DIFFERING EFFECTS OF POTENCY AND EQUALLY CONCENTRATED DILUTION, Forschende Komplementarmedizin, 5(4), 1998, pp. 172-177
Introduction: Acid phosphatase from potato catalyzes the formation of
p-nitrophenol by splitting off the anorganic phosphate residue from p-
nitrophenylphosphate. This dephosphorylation reaction was analyzed in
the presence of two test substances Objective: The main target of thes
e investigations was to ascertain differences in the effects of homoeo
pathic potency and equally concentrated conventional dilution on the a
ctivity of this enzyme by Variation of assay conditions. Methods: As t
est substances cAMP and ubiquinone in the potency D8 and the dilution
10(-8) were used. In the presence of these preparations the catalytic
activity of acid phosphatase was determined by a spectrophotometric as
say. Results: 1. When analyzing enzyme-catalyzed dephosphorylation rea
ction under standard conditions (time of incubation 5 min at 30 degree
s C) in the presence of cAMP and ubiquinone, respectively, it was foun
d that both substances inhibited the catalytic activity of acid phosph
atase. 2. While differing effects of homoeopathic potency and equally
concentrated dilution of the rest substance ubiquinone could be detect
ed, in the case of cAMP such a difference - even when the time of incu
bation was varied - was not found. 3. After modification of the assay
conditions (pre-incubation of the enzyme together with the agent for 2
0 min at 30 degrees C) the homoeopathic potency D8 and the dilution 10
(-8) of cAMP differed in their impact upon enzyme-catalyzed substrate
dephosphorylation. In the case of ubiquinone the difference already fo
und under standard conditions could be enhanced. Conclusions: 1. With
the help of a cell-free system it is possible to detect differing effe
cts of potency and equally concentrated dilution. Thereby it is not on
ly important to combine the 'right' enzyme system with the 'appropriat
e' agent, but to vary and modify the conditions of the assay system. 2
. As the results show, parts of the basic research in homoeopathy can
be presented independently of an intact organism.