D. Melchart et al., OBSERVATIONAL STUDIES IN A NETWORK OF HOSPITALS USING COMPLEMENTARY MEDICINE - PART I - METHODS AND COMPARATIVE OVERVIEW OF THE RESULTS, Forschende Komplementarmedizin, 5(1), 1998, pp. 18-25
Background: In Germany a considerable number of in-patient facilities
offer complementary medicine in addition to conventional care. In this
study we aimed to describe patient characteristics, diagnostics, ther
apy and outcomes of four such in-patient facilities. Methods: 2835 con
secutive in-patients admitted to two private hospitals with an emphasi
s on complementary medical cart, one private hospital for traditional
Chinese medicine, and the Department of Complementary Medicine of a pu
blic district hospital participated in a prospective observational (co
hort) study with 12 months follow-up. Sociodemographic characteristics
, diagnoses, duration of disease, type and frequency of therapeutic in
terventions, intensity of complaints, assessment of therapeutic succes
s, and quality of life were documented. Results: Patients of the obser
ved hospitals were mostly female (66%-80% in the four hospitals) and a
high proportion was chronically ill (31%-62% with a disease history l
onger than 5 years). The frequency of single diagnoses varied strongly
between the four hospitals, however, chronic pain syndromes were very
frequent in all. Complementary care always included a large number of
different therapeutic methods whose combination varied with different
diagnoses and between the hospitals. At discharge, 57%-73% of patient
s rated the therapeutic success as good or very good, Follow-up rates
were satisfactory only in two of the four hospitals. After 12 months 5
1%-64% of the responding patients still rated the success as good or v
ery good. Conclusions: In the observed hospitals mainly chronically il
l patients are treated with highly complex combinations of a large var
iety of complementary therapies. A majority of patients seems to be sa
tisfied by the treatment. A major methodological problem in the interp
retations of patient outcomes are the partly low followup rates.