Sw. Smith et al., TOTAL HIP-ARTHROPLASTY WITH USE OF 2ND-GENERATION CEMENTING TECHNIQUES - AN 18-YEAR-AVERAGE FOLLOW-UP-STUDY, Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume (Print ed.), 80A(11), 1998, pp. 1632-1640
In this report, we present the results of a further follow-up of a ser
ies of 140 consecutive patients (161 hips) who had had a primary total
hip arthroplasty with insertion of a bead-blasted monoblock femoral c
omponent with use of so called second-generation cementing techniques.
The average age of the patients at the time of the arthroplasty was s
ixty-one Sears (range, twenty-one to eighty-five years), Sixty-seven p
atients (seventy-seven hips) died less than seventeen years after the
index operation. The remaining seventy-three patients (eighty-four hip
s) were followed for an average of eighteen years (range, seventeen to
twenty years), No patient was lost to follow-up, In the entire group
of 161 hips, over the twenty-year span of the study eight femoral comp
onents (5 percent) and twenty-eight acetabular components (17 percent)
had been revised because of aseptic loosening, Of the seventy-seven h
ips in the sixty-seven patients who died, four had been revised becaus
e of aseptic loosening of the acetabular component only; one, because
of aseptic loosening of the femoral component only; and one, because o
f aseptic loosening of both components. Of the eighty-four hips in the
seventy-three patients who were alive at least seventeen years after
the index arthroplasty, twenty-four hips (29 percent) in twenty-one pa
tients had had revision of one or both components for any reason, Twen
ty-three acetabular components (27 percent) and six femoral components
(7 percent) had been revised because of aseptic loosening, An additio
nal two hips (2 percent) in two patients were loose according to radio
graphic criteria but had not been revised, Of the sixty-five all-polye
thylene acetabular components that had been inserted with cement and w
ere in patients who were alive at least seventeen years postoperativel
y, fifteen (23 percent) had been revised because of aseptic loosening.
An additional seventeen cups (26 percent) were loose according to rad
iographic criteria. Thus, a total of thirty-two cups (49 percent) had
been revised because of loosening or were loose but had not been revis
ed at the time of the latest follow-up. The femoral components that ha
d been inserted with use of second-generation cementing techniques far
ed better than did the acetabular components that had been inserted wi
th these techniques during the same time-period. We found that assessm
ent of all postoperative radiographs rather than only those that had b
een made immediately postoperatively increased the accuracy of the gra
ding of the cement around the femoral component, Subsequent radiograph
s frequently had been made at different projections, which revealed ne
w findings, consisting primarily of previously undetected voids, areas
of thin cement, and; defects in the cement mantle, Thus, we now use a
ll available radiographs to determine the grade of the cement.