Me. Allaf et al., LAPAROSCOPIC VISUAL-FIELD - VOICE VS FOOT PEDAL INTERFACES FOR CONTROL OF THE AESOP ROBOT, Surgical endoscopy, 12(12), 1998, pp. 1415-1418
Background: In order for robotic devices to be introduced successfully
into surgical practice, the development of transparent surgeon/machin
e interfaces is critical. Methods: This study evaluated the standard f
oot pedal for the AESOP robot compared to a voice control interface. S
peed, accuracy, learning curves, durability of learning at 2 weeks, an
d operator-interface failures were analyzed in an ex vivo model. Resul
ts: Foot control was faster and had less operator-interface failures.
Voice control was more accurate as measured by ''pass points.'' The fo
ot control learning curve reached a plateau at the third trial, while
the voice control did not fully plateau. Durability of learning favore
d the foot control but was not significantly different. Conclusions: C
urrently, the voice control is more accurate and has the advantage of
not requiring the surgeon to look away from the operative field. Howev
er, it is slower and may require more attention as an interface. As vo
ice recognition software continues to advance, speed and transparency
are anticipated to improve.